Grilled Halibut & Sweet Pepper Salad for Father’s Day

‘Tis the season of salads, and Father’s Day is worth splurging on premium fish for a protein-packed meal to serve proudly to the Dad in your life. This recipe for Grilled Halibut & Sweet Pepper Salad is made with the ultimate white fish. Halibut is dense, substantial, grills gorgeously, and presents a crescendo of snowy, firm fillet when roasted or grilled. It’s one of the best fish for a hearty appetite. Now halibut can be pricey, but it’s worth the dollars when you find a beautiful portion to serve to a deserving dad.

Halibut and Sustainability

The Environmental Defense Fund (EDF) Seafood Selector states that halibut, the largest flat fish, is subject to strict catch guidelines in U.S. Atlantic waters.  Depletion of halibut stock resulted in restrictions against targeting of the fish by commercial fishermen. If you come across a package of Atlantic halibut, it may have been caught as part of commercial bycatch (hauled in with the target fish), which the regulations allow. 
Sustainable halibut comes from Pacific Ocean fisheries near Alaska and Canada. Pacific halibut are from mindfully managed fisheries that have contributed far less environmental damage to halibut habitat (these are bottom-dwelling fish). Look for Pacific Halibut from Alaska or Canada.

What About Mercury?

To be straight, all ocean creatures absorb methylmercury (which is what mercury becomes when it comes into contact with bacteria.) So the challenge for seafood lovers is to eat more short-lived, smaller fish (i.e. sardines, tilapia, freshwater trout) and fewer of the bigger, long-lived fish (i.e. swordfish, Ahi or Bigeye tuna).  Since halibut is a long-lived fish–the oldest on record was 55 years old–there is more of a chance for halibut to absorb and store methylmercury in its flesh. According to EDF, halibut can be safely eaten by adult men and women four-plus times per month, by children aged 6-12, three times per month, and by children aged 0-5 one time per month. See this chart for more information. 

Recipe: Grilled Halibut & Sweet Pepper Salad (Serves 3)
1.5 pounds Pacific Halibut (Alaskan or Canadian), cut into thirds
Kosher salt and cracked pepper
1/4 cup grapeseed oil (or another high-heat-tolerant cooking oil)
1/2 cup Miso Tamari sauce (or 1/2 cup Tamari sauce and 1/2 teaspoon white miso)
1/4 cup brown rice vinegar
1 tablespoon honey
1 yellow or orange bell pepper, cleaned and cut in half
1 red bell pepper, cleaned and cut in half
2 cups mixed lettuce, cleaned 
1 cup prepared, sweet corn

  1. Put fish in a large, glass bowl to rinse it. Remove rinsed fish and pat dry with paper towels. Transfer dry fillets to a clean cutting board used only for seafood and meats. Brush each halibut portion with grapeseed or other cooking oil and season with salt and pepper. 
  2. Mix together miso tamari, rice vinegar, and honey to create a quick marinade. Divide the marinade into two portions and set one portion aside. Brush each side of halibut portions with marinade.
  3. Place each fillet portion on a hot grill or stovetop grill pan. Grill fish on one side for five minutes. With a fish spatula or non-stick fish turner, lift fish gently and partially from grill to test if it will release easily from the grill. If a portion of the fish sticks to the grill, allow it to cook for another minute and test for release again. 
  4. When fish is ready to be turned, turn it and continue grilling until reaches an internal temperature of 145 degrees. If using a stovetop grill pan, turn fish and place in a 400-degree oven until internal temperature is 145 degrees. Place fish aside.
  5. Grill sweet pepper halves on both sides and remove from grill. When pepper halves are cool enough handle, slice into 1-inch strips.
  6. Put handful of lettuce mix on serving plates. Top each lettuce portion with grilled halibut, grilled pepper strips, and garnish salad with sweet corn. Pour reserved marinade sparingly over each salad.

Veganize It!

Substitute halibut for thick slices of eggplant. 
Follow Me!
Follow Me!

Latest posts by Alaiyo Kiasi-Barnes (see all)


  1. says

    Ooooh, I love the eggplant idea!! I immediately started thinking tofu as I read the recipe but I think the eggplant would be so much better. It absorbs flavors so well and the combination of the marinade & the smokey “grill” flavors would be so nice. Mmm … the peppers are the “Pièce de résistance”. We’ve been talking about firing up the grill … I think this would be the perfect recipe to try out! Thanks, Alaiyo! :-)

  2. says

    It’s funny, but all the while, as I wrote the post, I thought of tofu as well and then thought of the added flavors and thought that eggplant would also work well. Thanks so much for thinking to stop by and comment. I so appreciate it!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *